Supreme Court Orders Raise Concerns Among Retired Bureaucrats on Environmental Issues

Recently, a group of 79 retired civil servants and diplomats shared their worries over three significant orders from the Supreme Court regarding environmental issues. In an open letter, these former bureaucrats expressed how these decisions could harm the interests of citizens and affect the conservation of nature in India. They urged the Supreme Court to prioritize the well-being of citizens over the interests of corporations, which they believe are wasting public resources.

The retired officials belong to an organization called the Constitutional Conduct Group. They voiced their “deep anguish” over a recent change where the Supreme Court retracted an earlier ruling that had prohibited retrospective environment clearances for developmental projects. Additionally, they criticized a new definition of the Aravalli Hills and a decision that prevents the government from disbanding the Central Empowered Committee without the court’s approval.

Retrospective Clearances: A Step Backward

Earlier this year, a two-judge bench of the Supreme Court had barred the Union government from granting retrospective clearances to regularize illegal constructions. However, on November 18, a three-judge bench decided, by a 2:1 vote, to allow the government to consider granting these clearances again. The retired bureaucrats highlighted their concerns, reminding everyone that issues like severe air pollution in Delhi and extreme weather events sweeping across the country should compel the court to act quickly. They hope that a larger bench will review the case and restore the earlier ruling soon.

New Definition of Aravallis: A Risk to the Environment

On November 20, the Supreme Court accepted a new definition for the Aravalli Hills, categorizing them based on height—landforms rising 100 meters above local levels. Environmentalists are worried that this definition might disregard many lower hills that are essential for ecological balance. The former bureaucrats noted that the Aravalli range plays a crucial role in slowing down desert expansion and recharging groundwater.

Their letter highlighted that the new definition could remove over 90% of the Aravalli range from environmental protection, opening it up for mining and construction. This could have severe consequences, such as increased desertification around Delhi and a loss of habitat for local wildlife like leopards and hyenas. Although the Supreme Court has shown some concern by agreeing to look into the new definition, the urgency of this matter cannot be understated.

Central Empowered Committee: A Question of Integrity

Another pressing issue raised by the retired civil servants concerns the Central Empowered Committee (CEC), originally established to oversee compliance with environmental laws. The Supreme Court recently ruled that the Union government cannot disband the CEC without the court’s permission. The retired officials pointed out that the committee’s current members have begun to lean towards supporting harmful government actions, undermining its original purpose.

They observed that a member of the CEC was part of the Expert Committee responsible for defining the Aravallis, which raises questions about the committee’s independence and integrity. If the CEC continues to be swayed by government interests, the long-term consequences could be detrimental to environmental conservation efforts and the health of citizens.

The Call for Urgent Action

The former bureaucrats made it clear that they believe the Supreme Court must take swift action on these pressing environmental concerns. The state’s duty to protect nature and the health of its citizens must not be compromised in favor of corporate interests.

The retired officials’ heartfelt appeal reminds us that protecting the environment is not just a legal obligation but a moral one. It ensures a sustainable future for the coming generations and safeguards the rights of individuals to live in a healthy and safe environment.

As the situation develops, citizens will be watching closely to see how these issues are addressed. There’s an urgent need for those responsible for environmental governance to listen to these concerns and act accordingly.

Let’s hope that the Supreme Court takes the necessary steps to prioritize nature and public health in all its decisions.

EnvironmentalAwareness #SupremeCourt #SustainableFuture #ProtectNature #AravalliHills #CitizenRights #EcoJustice

Original Text – https://scroll.in/latest/1089629/sc-must-prioritise-environmental-concerns-over-corporate-waste-of-money-say-ex-bureaucrats?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=public