Centre Opposes Plea to Reduce GST on Air Purifiers

On a recent Friday, the Union government presented its arguments in the Delhi High Court, opposing a request to reduce the Goods and Services Tax (GST) on air purifiers from 18% to 5%. This plea, made in a public interest litigation by advocate Kapil Madan, aims to classify air purifiers as “medical devices” and seek a lower tax rate due to the worsening air quality in Delhi.

The court, led by Justices Vikas Mahajan and Vinod Kumar, had directed the GST Council to convene an urgent meeting earlier this week to discuss lowering the levies on air purifiers. During the latest hearing, Additional Solicitor General N. Venkataraman, representing the Union government, expressed concerns that a hasty reduction in GST—without following the required procedures—could lead to unintended consequences, often referred to as opening a “Pandora’s box.”

The Importance of Due Process

Venkataraman elaborated on the legislative process involved when it comes to recommendations made by parliamentary standing committees. He argued that the GST Council, which is constitutionally established, should not be bypassed by court orders. “How can this process be scuttled through a court process?” he asked, highlighting the importance of all states and the Union government having a seat at the table when such decisions are made.

Madan, however, countered this argument by stressing the urgent need for action. He pointed out that residents of Delhi are suffering due to high pollution levels, which necessitates a quick response. “The clean air is taxed, and it is being taxed wrongly,” he insisted. The court acknowledged these concerns and noted that any decisions would need to await the upcoming GST Council meeting.

The Court’s Concern

The additional solicitor general also questioned whether a public interest litigation was the right approach, suggesting that the petitioner could instead present his case directly to the government. But Madan maintained that his argument was not adversarial; he simply aimed to demonstrate that the existing tax framework for air purifiers is flawed.

The court echoed the sentiments of Madan, emphasizing the importance of addressing the high costs associated with air purifiers. The justices questioned why the tax couldn’t be reduced to make these essential devices affordable for the common man. “An air purifier costs between Rs 10,000 and Rs 15,000. Why not bring down the GST to a level where every individual can purchase one?” they queried.

The Ongoing Pollution Crisis in Delhi

The urgency of this issue has been further underlined by the deteriorating air quality in Delhi, which has been fluctuating between “very poor” and “severe.” The Air Quality Index (AQI) recently recorded a value of 336, indicating very poor air conditions affecting the health of residents. With increasing pollution levels, the need for air purifiers becomes all the more critical.

Various factors contribute to Delhi’s air pollution crisis, including vehicular emissions, industrial discharges, and the seasonal practice of stubble burning in neighboring states. During the winter months, air quality tends to worsen significantly due to lower temperatures and decreased wind speeds, making it hard for pollutants to disperse.

What’s Next?

The court has instructed the Union government to submit a detailed response within ten days, with the next hearing scheduled for January 9. It’s clear that this issue is not just a legal matter; it’s a pressing public health concern that requires immediate action.

As people in Delhi continue to grapple with high pollution levels, the discussion surrounding the GST on air purifiers will not only affect businesses but could significantly influence health outcomes for millions of residents.

This situation serves as a reminder of the need for swift and effective governance in addressing one of the most serious urban health issues of our time.

Final Thoughts

In conclusion, as discussions continue in the court and government circles, the focus should remain on the urgent need for cleaner air and affordable solutions. It is essential that all stakeholders work together to ensure better air quality for all residents of Delhi.

Related Hashtags:

DelhiPollution #AirPurifiers #GSTReduction #CleanAir #HealthForAll #DelhiHighCourt #EnvironmentalAwareness #PollutionCrisis #PublicHealth

Original Text – https://scroll.in/latest/1089593/will-open-pandoras-box-centre-opposes-plea-seeking-reduction-of-gst-on-air-purifiers?utm_source=rss&utm_medium=public